Woods Battle - Key Tactics

 Hello everyone, this will be the second of two posts about Pennsic 51 melee tactics.  If you haven't already, please see the post regarding the town battle.

The basic concept is the same.  Each side has a resurrection point.  Somewhere in the middle a battle front forms, and there is a flag that needs to be controlled.  The side that is better gets more kills, which pushes the battle front closer to the other team's resurrection point, which means that that team will have a shorter walk to the resurrection point, allowing them to replenish their ranks more quickly which creates a balance in the forces.

In the case of last week's battle, the other team had us (the Southern Army) close to our resurrection point.



We struggled against the Midrealm (red) for a few reasons;  they out numbered us, significantly, they had an uphill advantage (this is a real thing), and they're main unit, Dark Moon (in the gold and black that day) is a well trained, well organized melee unit.

When we are outmatched like that, the only thing we can really do is retreat as it is an unwinnable situation.  You may have heard me say many times, "fall back," or, "displace," which means, "Get the hell out of there, walk away, and reposition 10-20 feet back."  It's better to walk back 20 feet than to die and walk all the way back to the resurrection point.

Now, just like the town battle, the priorities are the same:

1)  Go for the flag
2)  Control the extreme flank
3)  Look for gaps in the line


Additionally I'll add that along with "gaps" you can look for "weaknesses," in the line, where you can create gaps.  This could be a collection of bad fighters, or a bad weapons mix, like an area with no spears.

So let's break it down one priority at a time.

1)  Go for the flag

The problem here is that the flag tends to be well protected, and with regard to the woods battle, going for the flag puts you in a kill pocket.  This is because you are not at the edge or the world, a wall, or a terrain feature like a lake, but rather there are more fighters in the woods as you move (in this case) to blue's left.

The picture below includes the fighters to the left of us so that you can see why a kill pocket forms when blue pushes for the flag.


2)  Control the Extreme Flank

We were just overwhelmed on this flank.  Dark Moon had a well organized, well trained, well skilled unit that was bigger than us and had an uphill advantage.  We couldn't pick them apart with spears, nor could we charge into them and expect any positive results.



3)  Look for Gaps in the Line

Ultimately we were able to exploit a weakness in the enemy.  To the right was Dark Moon, which was strong.  To our left were the Tuchux, who were also strong.  But between the two units was a collection of Ealdomere fighters who were a little thinner in their ranks, and not quite as organized or skilled (though they had a handful of high level fighters).  

Here, myself, Sir Gowain, Sir Hassan, and Sir Jonathan (four veteran spears), moved into that gap and were able to whittle away at Ealdomere.  Once we created a gap, we were able to roll down the hill into Dark Moon's flank, and ultimately take out the entire unit.  

1st pic is redeploying to attack the weakness.


And then attacking the flank of the strong unit.


This is something that the Southern Army actually does well while most well trained units don't.  Dark Moon could have easily had just a handful of fighters redeploy to the center of this section of woods to resist our focussed attack, but they are trained to stay with the unit, and likely even to stay within their defined triads.

At Southern Army Sundays, we do a lot of broken field resurrection battles so that fighters can learn to read and adapt to a static line battle, which is what our veteran spears did here.

I'd like to add that normally this kind of redeployment would leave the extreme flank weakened.  Because they were pushing us against our resurrection point, they made it clear that they would not be pressing any further on that flank.  So while they were content to "stay the line" on that flank, we were able to pick apart the weakness between the two units.

What We Could Have Done Better

Though we routed them several times, we only pushed for the flag once (and we got it!).  We were content to just wait for them to return to the same spot in the woods, and forgot to make a big push for the flag.  Remember this in future battles.  REMIND ME in future battles.  This was the fault of the commanders, which falls on my shoulders as well, but it never hurts to send ideas like this up the chain.





Comments

Popular posts from this blog